Cape May Airbnb Realtor – Buy a Vacation or Short-Term Rental Property

A Cape May Airbnb Realtor connected through STR Realtor Search is your gateway to finding high-performing short-term rental properties in the area. We work exclusively with local agents who not only understand the Cape May housing market but also have real experience with what makes homes profitable as vacation rentals. Whether you're looking at single-family homes near the beach, stylish condos downtown, or multi-unit apartments that offer flexibility and cash flow, our vetted Realtors can help you spot the best opportunities before they hit the mainstream market. Through our parent company, Rise Collective, we go far beyond just connecting you to a Realtor. Our platform provides everything you need to succeed as an investor—from helping you get pre-approved through BNB Lending, to value-boosting renovations via BNB Construction, to full-service Airbnb management with Home Team Luxury Rentals. You can take the reins and be hands-on, or let us handle the entire process for you. We’ve designed the system to make investing in Cape May as efficient, data-driven, and profitable as possible.

Cape May is one of New Jersey’s premier historic and cultural destinations, ideal for STRs near Washington Street Mall, Congress Hall, and Beach Avenue. Guests come for events like the Cape May Music Festival, Victorian Weekend, and Christmas Candlelight House Tours. High-performing properties include Victorian homes, beachside condos, and updated inns with porches or carriage houses. Walkability to Cape May Winery, Emlen Physick Estate, and the beach trolley loop boosts demand. Investors should focus on legally zoned properties with charm, parking, and multi-season appeal. Cape May thrives on heritage tourism and return visitors.

Short-term rental regulations in New Jersey vary by municipality, and most smaller towns don’t have formal ordinances specifically addressing Airbnb or vacation rentals. In these areas, state laws apply—hosts must comply with New Jersey’s 6.625% sales tax and up to a 5% occupancy fee unless using a platform that handles tax collection. Local permitting is often not required, but HOA rules and zoning can still affect your ability to operate. These things can change quickly, so while we can provide general guidance here, it’s best to speak directly with us and the Realtor we’d match you with through STR Realtor Search to get the most current, location-specific insight.

Across the Jersey Shore, ideal short-term rental properties typically offer proximity to the beach, off-street parking, and at least 3 bedrooms to accommodate families or groups. Features like rooftop decks, outdoor showers, updated kitchens, and multi-zone HVAC add significant value. Walkability to restaurants, boardwalks, or beach access points is crucial for high occupancy. In southern areas like Cape May County, historic charm and porches boost appeal, while in northern spots like Long Beach Island, newer construction and bay views command premium rates. Investors should also ensure compliance with local ordinances, zoning, and seasonal permit requirements to avoid disruption.

Yes, we often analyze regional Airbnb data from sources like AirDNA and PriceLabs to highlight high-performing properties across the Jersey Shore. In areas such as Ocean City, Wildwood, and LBI, many short-term rentals consistently earn 70–90% occupancy during summer with average daily rates exceeding $400. We track key performance indicators including RevPAR , booking lead time, and guest reviews, and use this data to benchmark potential properties. Investor clients can view anonymized case studies and aggregated review trends to better understand what drives success in different zones along the coast.

Absolutely. We maintain a curated list of featured listings across the Jersey Shore that meet key vacation rental investment criteria. These include homes with existing STR permits, proven rental history, and proximity to high-demand attractions like boardwalks, marinas, and downtown dining. Many of our featured properties are already furnished and income-generating, while others are positioned for value-add upgrades. Whether you're looking in Cape May County, Ocean County, or Monmouth County, we can connect you with listings that align with your income goals and timeline.

We don’t outsource property management — we handle it in-house through Home Team Luxury Rentals , part of the Rise Collective. As one of the fastest-growing and highest-rated independently owned property management companies in the U.S., Home Team delivers full-service short-term rental management with a focus on performance, guest experience, and investor satisfaction.

While STR Realtor Search collaborates with top-performing real estate agents and agencies across the Jersey Shore and New Jersey, property management is fully integrated within our ecosystem. This ensures investors benefit from a unified strategy, seamless communication, and best-in-class operational excellence without relying on third-party managers or cohosts.

In addition, we have the full time attention of Ricardo Carillo, a trusted STR mortgage broker , to find you the best deal for financing!

We work with experienced short-term rental Realtors across the entire Jersey Shore to help you find the right property in the right market. Whether you're looking for luxury beachfront homes, high-yield multifamily opportunities, or value-add investments in emerging areas, we have trusted professionals ready to assist. Below are the locations we currently cover:


- Perth Amboy
- South Amboy
- Laurence Harbor
- Cliffwood Beach
- Union Beach
- Keansburg
- Keyport
- Atlantic Highlands
- Highlands
- Sandy Hook
- Sea Bright
- Monmouth Beach
- Long Branch
- Elberon
- Deal
- Allenhurst
- Loch Arbour
- Asbury Park
- Ocean Grove
- Bradley Beach
- Avon-by-the-Sea
- Belmar
- Spring Lake
- Sea Girt
- Manasquan
- Point Pleasant Beach
- Bay Head
- Mantoloking
- Normandy Beach
- Chadwick Beach Island
- Brick Township
- Dover Beaches North
- Ortley Beach
- Lavallette
- Dover Beaches South
- Seaside Heights
- Seaside Park
- Island Beach
- Barnegat Light
- Loveladies
- Harvey Cedars
- North Beach
- Surf City
- Ship Bottom
- Beach Haven Crest
- Beach Haven
- Brant Beach
- Brigantine
- Atlantic City
- Ventnor City
- Margate City
- Longport
- Ocean City
- Strathmere
- Sea Isle City
- Avalon
- Stone Harbor
- North Wildwood
- Wildwood
- Wildwood Crest
- Diamond Beach