Find a Cave Creek Airbnb Realtor That Knows Airbnb, Short Term Rentals, and Vacation Rentals Inside and Out

Frequently Asked Questions for Airbnb Investment Properties

How can an Airbnb Realtor or agent help me find high-performing rentals in Cave Creek, AZ?

A Cave Creek Airbnb Realtor connected through STR Realtor Search can help you find high-performing short-term rental properties in one of Arizona’s most unique and character-rich towns. Known for its rugged desert landscape, Western charm, and upscale yet unpretentious lifestyle, Cave Creek attracts travelers looking for an authentic Sonoran experience. Whether you’re considering homes near downtown Cave Creek’s saloons and art galleries, equestrian properties on larger lots, or high-desert retreats with mountain views, our local agents know which areas deliver strong rental income and year-round guest interest.

Backed by our parent company, Rise Collective, we offer full-service vacation rental management in Cave Creek , so you can generate passive income without the operational stress. From professional listing setup and dynamic pricing to guest services and property upkeep, we help you deliver a premium experience that matches Cave Creek’s elevated rustic vibe.

With its proximity to Tonto National Forest, outdoor events, and a steady stream of visitors seeking a quieter alternative to Scottsdale, Cave Creek is a prime spot for Airbnb investment. We help you tap into that demand with local expertise and a full-service approach built for long-term success.

What neighborhoods are best for short-term rental income in Cave Creek, Arizona?

Cave Creek offers a unique opportunity for short-term rental investors looking to blend rustic charm with upscale living. With its Western heritage, desert landscapes, and close proximity to North Scottsdale, Cave Creek attracts a wide range of Airbnb guests—from outdoor adventurers to luxury travelers. Here are the top neighborhoods and areas in Cave Creek for short-term rental income:

Tatum Ranch
One of Cave Creek’s more established and accessible neighborhoods, Tatum Ranch features affordable single-family homes near golf courses and shopping. It appeals to snowbirds, families, and travelers looking for quiet comfort near Scottsdale.

Rancho Mañana
Surrounding the Rancho Mañana Golf Club, this area offers scenic views, luxury homes, and walkability to restaurants and galleries in downtown Cave Creek. It's a top choice for higher-end guests and couples booking weekend getaways.

Downtown Cave Creek (Historic Core)
This central area is rich in local character, with walkable access to saloons, art shops, and live music venues. Rentals here are popular with travelers looking for a Western experience. Smaller homes, casitas, and uniquely styled properties perform especially well.

Desert Foothills North
For guests seeking privacy, mountain views, and a desert retreat atmosphere, this part of Cave Creek delivers. Homes on larger lots with outdoor amenities attract groups, family reunions, and long-stay guests.

Stagecoach Village Area
Near the Stagecoach Village shopping and event space, this area sees good short-term demand during festivals and seasonal events. Homes here benefit from both proximity and charm, making it a versatile investment zone.

Home Team Rentals , also a Rise Collective company, provides vacation rental management in Cave Creek.

Do you partner with property managers or cohosting services based here?

We don’t outsource property management — we handle it in-house through Home Team Luxury Rentals , part of the Rise Collective. As one of the fastest-growing and highest-rated independently owned property management companies in the U.S., Home Team delivers full-service short-term rental management with a focus on performance, guest experience, and investor satisfaction.

While STR Realtor Search collaborates with top-performing real estate agents and agencies throughout Arizona and across the U.S., property management is fully integrated within our ecosystem. This ensures investors benefit from a unified strategy, seamless communication, and best-in-class operational excellence without relying on third-party managers or cohosts.

In addition, we have the full-time attention of Ricardo Carillo, a trusted STR mortgage broker , to find you the best deal for financing!

Can you provide data (and possibly reviews) on successful Airbnb investments in the area?

Yes, we frequently analyze regional Airbnb data from platforms like AirDNA and PriceLabs to identify high-performing properties across Arizona. In key markets such as Phoenix, Scottsdale, and Sedona, many short-term rentals consistently achieve occupancy rates between 55–70%, with average daily rates (ADR) ranging from $180 to $325 depending on the season, home type, and proximity to local attractions.

For instance, in Scottsdale, short-term rentals average an occupancy rate of around 62% with an ADR of $294, leading to average annual revenue figures exceeding $60,000 for well-located, professionally managed properties. Sedona remains a top performer year-round due to its tourism-driven demand, while cities like Tempe and Flagstaff also attract steady bookings tied to universities, events, and outdoor recreation.

We track key performance indicators including RevPAR (Revenue Per Available Room), booking lead time, and guest review volume to benchmark potential investment opportunities. This data-driven approach allows us to provide investor clients with anonymized case studies and aggregated review trends, offering insights into what drives success in different regions of Arizona.

For example, in the Phoenix metro area, suburban neighborhoods near spring training stadiums and event venues have seen rising demand, while luxury homes in North Scottsdale continue to command premium pricing and longer booking windows from snowbirds and group travelers.

If you're interested, we can provide detailed data reports or case studies tailored to your specific Arizona market or neighborhood of interest.

What should I look for in an Airbnb investment property in the Phoenix metro area beyond just location?

While location is critical, it’s only one piece of what makes a short-term rental successful in the Phoenix metro market. The most profitable Airbnb investments combine guest-focused design, operational efficiency, and long-term compliance readiness. Here’s what to prioritize beyond the map pin:

• Legal and Regulatory Fit – Make sure the property is in a city or zone that allows short-term rentals and meets all local licensing, safety, and parking requirements.

• Guest Appeal and Amenities – Properties with features like private pools, outdoor dining areas, smart home tech, and open-concept layouts consistently attract higher nightly rates and better reviews.

• Design for Flexibility – Homes with multiple bedrooms, functional workspaces, and comfortable gathering areas appeal to a wider range of guest types—from families and snowbirds to digital nomads.

• Property Condition and Upgrade Potential – Turnkey properties or those with high-ROI renovation potential tend to perform better, especially when optimized for Airbnb with the help of our team at BNB Turnkey and BNB Construction.

• Noise, Privacy, and Parking – Quiet surroundings, ample parking, and good noise insulation can improve guest satisfaction while helping you stay in good standing with neighbors and local regulators.

• Historical Performance Data – We evaluate AirDNA, PriceLabs, and other STR data platforms to benchmark potential earnings based on occupancy, ADR, RevPAR, and local competition.

Our Phoenix-area Airbnb Realtors, through STR Realtor Search, work with you to evaluate all of these criteria before you buy—ensuring that your investment is both guest-ready and future-proof.

What makes a house — or other property types like condos or townhomes — ideal for short-term rentals in this market?

In the Phoenix metro area, short-term rental properties perform best when they blend smart location choices, guest-centric amenities, and regulatory compliance. Proximity to major attractions—such as sports venues, shopping districts, universities, and outdoor recreation—drives strong year-round demand, especially during peak travel seasons like winter and spring.

What makes a property ideal isn’t just where it is, but how well it serves guest needs. Homes with resort-style features—like private pools, shaded patios, and open indoor/outdoor living areas—tend to outperform. Interiors that are modern, spacious, and designed for groups or families are also key, especially when paired with conveniences like smart home tech, high-speed Wi-Fi, and flexible layouts.

Local ordinances across the metro vary, so properties that are already in permitted zones and meet licensing, safety, and parking requirements offer a clearer path to profitability. Compliance isn’t optional—it’s part of creating a stable, long-term STR investment.

Finally, properties that support longer stays and cater to a variety of travelers—whether vacationers, snowbirds, or remote workers—have a competitive edge. The most successful rentals in this market are designed for both comfort and compliance, offering memorable guest experiences while aligning with metro-wide travel trends and seasonal demand.

STR Realtor Search > Arizona > Cave Creek

Nearby markets:

Scottsdale ,
Carefree ,
Anthem ,
Fountain Hills ,
New River ,
Paradise Valley ,
Rio Verde ,
Tempe ,
Guadalupe